Quantcast

SATURDAY SURVEY: Desert island: Twilight books or movies?

January 29, 2011  Posted by Lindsay in Poll,Twilight

If you were stuck on a desert island and could only take either the Twilight books OR movies, which would you take? Tell us why in the comments below, or discuss it in the chat!

See and vote in previous Saturday Surveys here!

← Older Comments
  • Breezii

    BOOKS!!  No Fan Of K.S's crappy acting. also in the first 2 movies jasper didnt have a texas accent. than boom in the 3rd one he sounded all hick.

  • Alejalozano17

    Ok…. I love the books i have read them millions of times, i think the movies have been great pass the first one and even the people that work in it is great. especially Rob ;) !! The way Meyer write and make descriptions is amazing so i definitely choose the books.. Plus in a desert island theres no way in which i can be able to see the movies Lol (no electricity).. If someone care about I am a Colombian girl and even here the fever for the twilight saga is unbelievable  !! 

  • TheColombian

    Ok…. I love the books i have read them millions of times, i think the movies have been great pass the first one and even the people that work in it is great. especially Rob ;) !! The way Meyer write and make descriptions is amazing so i definitely choose the books.. Plus in a desert island theres no way in which i can be able to see the movies Lol (no electricity).. If someone care about I am a Colombian girl and even here the fever for the twilight saga is unbelievable  !!

  • Breezii

    BOOKS!!  No Fan Of K.S's crappy acting. also in the first 2 movies jasper didnt have a texas accent. than boom in the 3rd one he sounded all hick.

  • kirsten

    the books because i love reading and you can make a 'movie' up in your head. plus te books have so much more info in them than the films do. the books can keep you entertained for about 4/5 hours. the films only last 1 1/2 hours.

  • Sandycat53

    it would have to be my twilight books as it would not be possible to watch a dvd on a desert island as there would be no electricity. but would be even better to have rob there with me lol!

  • Sandycat53

    ok so before anyone says anything a woman can dream cant she lol?

  • KAylaBooskii

    Books it has more detail and description. And more room to let your mind wander. The only exception is new moon

  • peggy soule

    One thing is that the books take a couple days to read, but movies are finished in 2 hrs.  As much as I like to look at RPatz and Taylor L.,it's more fun to imagine what they look like.  The books are so much better than the movies due to needing to leave so much out of the movies.  Me.Twilight series, a deserted island, and a couple bottles of good wine and I'm set for a great time.

  • Elated-life

    They leave All the realy important bits that help u understand out of the movies  like i only found out that jacob could live for ever like the vampires could because of the story and desert island means no electricity so books ftw!

  • Sarah McCoy

    I would take the books, because they are better then most of the movies! They forget too much of the important stuff in the movies! The only reason I would even think about taking the movies is so I can see Edward (ROB) over and over and over again! And to watch Bella (KRISTEN) knock the crap out of Jacob! LOL that was classic!!!!!!!!! I am hoping they don't screw up Breaking Dawn! I will be soo bumbed because that was by far thee best book!

  • Kellan'sFutureWife

    The Books for 3 reasons

    1) Deserted Island = NO ELECTRICITY, and no electricity means no power for a laptop/tv and dvd/blueray player, which means you can't actually watch the movies. (Did the 289 voters for the movies think about that?)
    2)The books are WAY better than the movies (but that is simply because you can't make a movie as good as a book it is based off of….it is impossible

    3) The movies cut out some of my favorite lines and scenes :( The book still has them :)

  • Kellan'sFutureWife

    WHY THE HELL WOULD YOU WANT TO BURN THE BOOKS?!?!?! Or any books for that matter? That is just stupid

  • Twilight4eva

    I would totally take th books, they consume more time ad i think they'd keep me from going insane more than the movies would!

  • Trishkadawn

    Most Definitely the books, cause I can use my own imagination.  I love making my own movie in my head when I read. Plus the books have more detail than the movies. Also how would you watch the movies anyway? Plug it into a tree or bush? LOL

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_H4HJKCYGAHACHICUVWMD4HAR2M Christiana Holiday

    if your done reading twilight you should also read this series called vampire academy. since you say you love the details and such. another reason you should read it is because its “the heir to the twilight throne”. once twilight is over and vampire academy becomes a movie… this series will be all the rage. seeing as how twilight wasnt that popular untill the movies

  • dont for get to smile

    omg i read the vampire academy books they where amazing but i read the vampire academy after i read all the twilight books 7 times and whached the moves theat was out but i rely think vampire academy is going to hit it big when there move comes out but u shoullld read the books to u would fall in love whith them. and i cant pick if i llike the move or the book better.

  • Brandy Lewallen

    I love TWILIGHT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Patty

    Me too the books do have more detail then the movies I wish they would have put more of the stuff in the movies that was in the books.

  • Randirooroo

    HAHAHAHA im the same way i read the books 3 times after i watched Twilight for the first time and then i read the series every time a new movie cam out and since eclipse i have read breaking dawn 2 its my fav !!!!

  • ninelives4eva

    i think the movies r better i dont like to read but i decided to read the twilight saga and it was good but i detail puts me to sleep so i like the movies better and Taylor Lautner is hot so i vote movies

  • lovingrobantaylor

    movies so i could at least see hot guys

  • lovingrobantaylor

    both better stuff happens in the book but in the movies there are hot guys to look at. so both

  • Samantha<3

    I would pick the books because they're better but also because there's no electricity on a desert island so where would i watch the movies????

  • bob

    not to break it to you but…….. TEAM JACOB!!!!!!!!

  • Simmysimfreak

    i read the vampire academy books, i wouldn't compare them to twilight but they were awesome too :)

  • Someya

    The details are the best in the books every step every feeling en more. The movies brings this aspects just to live.

  • Nadine_ramzy

    The books are more detailed and stuff but I hate reading so my opinion is the movies!!

  • Oonaghmcg

    i like both buh would defo choose da books cnt wait fr  breacking dawn whoop

  • Rensemee Jacob Forever

    k if u were on a desert island u wuldnt have a tv or a dvd player. Plus Ive readd the hole series 427 times since they came out. i have a lot of time on my hands

← Older Comments

Have a tip?

Email story ideas to:
tips@team-twilight.com

Top Twilight Blogs