Variety ponders Summit’s ‘Twilight’ Dilemma

breaking dawn
[Cheers to Pablo for making this Breaking Dawn banner. Repeat, it is FAN MADE!]

A new article from Variety suggests that Summit has a delimma in dealing with production of a film version of the fourth book in the series, Breaking Dawn. Mainly, there is the money issue if they choose to make two more films, instead of one. In addition, they have figure out what director will be involved (Chris Weitz is a fan favorite).

They will likely have to cut a few big checks if they decided, as rumored, to split Stephenie Meyer’s final “Twilight” novel, “Breaking Dawn,” into two pictures. Sources said Summit has set Melissa Rosenberg — who wrote the first three films — to finish the series, but Summit has to clear several hurdles before Rosenberg learns how many more scripts she’ll write.

One of those hurdles is figuring out whether “New Moon” director Chris Weitz will respond favorably to overtures from the film company and the cast to shoot two more films, back to back.

Summit execs would not comment, but multiple sources said the company wants to go the two-film route, which means reopening negotiations and securing approval from the author. It also means making new deals with a principal cast that is only locked up for four films. If “Breaking Dawn” becomes two pictures, all of the key cast members will get fat raises, and the three principals — Robert Pattinson, Kristen Stewart and Taylor Lautner — could land paydays in the eight-figure range.

Read more here.

My guess is that the payoff at the box office will be big enough to warrent the extra expenditure on the front end.


  • i_love_jacob1234
    wow. im so excited, thats all i have to say
  • Jenny_Louise_Cullen
    Breaking Dawn was my favourite in the saga. It really should be made into a film. It would be pointless to go this far in a huge franchise and then not finish it off. It would probably have to have a higher rating than the others, but that won't stop Twi-hards going to see it over and over again!
  • ellaflan
    I think it would be better to split Breaking Dawn into 2 films. There wasnt one bit of the book that I didnt like so if they missed ANYTHING out, I would be majorly upset!! Also, the twilight saga wouldnt be over and done with in just four films... we would be able to stretch it all out and enjoy it all if it was split into two. :D
  • I say that as long as they get all the information that we're asking for in, I don't care how they make it. If it's one really long movie, I will faithfully sit through it, paying whatever price I have to and doing whatever it takes to get tickets for my friends and I because I am a big fan. If they decide to split it into two like 3 hour movies, I would prefer that, seeing as they could get more information in. Either way, I'll be their when it comes out, praying that they did the book justice.
  • georgiemayx
    2 movies is fine, for us to get the most out of it at least. its like with hp & the deathly hallows though.. if one single detail is missed out now that its in 2 films... i wont be happy.
  • edwardloverrr
    i cant wait to see bella as a vampire and i wanna see what she is gonna look like pregnant. And jacobs imprinting!!!! its gonna be sooooo good! plus i cant wait till eclipse so i can see Edward again <3
  • I would like to make an urgent request to all who think a 2-part Breaking Dawn would be a big mistake, if we start tweeting #OneFilmBreakingDawn, @Twilight might just see it. If we make them crazy enough, they might just consider making a 5-hour Breaking Dawn, like the case with Titanic, 2-hours, a break and 2-hours again.

    I really won't like it when Breaking Dawn gets cut in half, that would just screw up the whole plot and romance of the movie. Please Tweeters, UNITE against SUMMIT, include #OneFilmBreakingDawn AND (#Twilight or #NewMoon) in your tweets, so that we can get it trending.
  • jennah16
    i really dont want to have 2 movies, i rather have one LLONNNGGGG movie, but i like how there going to try to keep it as close to the book as they possibly can because breaking dawn is my fav book, and i want it like perfect, but if they make it two movies people can like forget some parts within a year, they made titanic 4 hours long, people sat through that, people most defiantly would sit through that time for breaking dawn. I WOULD!! robert pattinson DUHH!! haha
  • Please tweet #OneFilmBreakingDawn and (#Twilight or #NewMoon) and direct it at @Twilight, if you have Twitter. Please!
  • cher_grisell
    they can sure make breaking dawn, new moon made over 473 million, and they made new moon and eclipse on twilights 380 million. i say one movie with the wedding, honeymoon, birth, j.jenks squezzed in and the volturi. even though the book is split with book bella and book jacob he is still at the wedding and then at the cullens during and after the birth so it will all mesh for one movie
  • cher_grisell
    one movie will do just make it longer there have been longer movies. it would start out with the wedding, then honeymoon and back at home ( with jacob) during the birth and then j.jenks and the volutri they can make it one movie. i don't think splitting it would be very wise it doesn't matter if the book it split with book bella and book jacob b/c jacob is at the wedding for a little bit and at the cullens during the birth and stays the rest if its 3hrs that is just fine. and new moon has made 473 million they can sure make it, they made new moon and eclipse off of twilights 380 milion
  • sassyrebel4paul
    oh idont want chris 2 direct would really nice if catherine did since she did such a gd job with twilight!!!
  • justinbieber(L)
    i love the twilight saga. i would prefer if breaking dawn could be 1 movie because if it was 2 movies than i'd hav to wait a few months to see the other half, but if they have to make it into 2 movies than i guess thats ok. it really annoys me that some people only watch the movies because of the 'hot characters'. i do love the movies but the books are fantastic.
  • dEEKL
    It doesn't matter if they make Breaking Dawn in to two parts but if they do decide i want Chris Weitz to direct it and Catherine H. to handle the music!!! i loved chirs' directing in new moon but the music was okay....and on i loved the Catherine's music taste...each and every song was very catchy..however, i really hope they decide to make breaking dawn!!!
  • MrsG102707
    My theory is, yeah it would suck to have to wait AGAIN for Breaking Dawn Part 2...but if they put it all in one movie: 1. They will leave lots out! Even if it's 3 hours (Titanic was 3 hours and 14 minutes long) because they will never make one 6 hour movie. I seriously doubt that. That is more for made for TV movies that they play over a course of a week or weeks, 2. Who really wants to be done with the movies? Not I!!! I love knowing I haven't seen the last of The Twilight Sage movies.

    2 movies for sure would be ideal! Much more to loom forward to :)
  • Edward_Mine
    They should totally make it they cant stop now!!! what with all the money and ratings raining in and everyone waiting for the final instalment HOW CAN THEY SAY THEY'LL STOP!!! Fans are waiting!!! plus i wanna c ROB!!!
  • TeamJacward_Original
    I hope they make it into 2 movies. 1 would just be way too long, or have wayyyy to much cut out. Even if they have to have the actors commitment for another movie, I'm sure they would do it, mainly because of their dedication to the series and to give us a great movie series of the books, and because they would be the most hated people in the world if they decided to not par-take in a 2-part Breaking Dawn.
  • nessie09
    I totaly think there should be 2 movies i love the books so much and there is so much more they could fit in to 2 films ( more jacob and naked plaese lol ) i agree that it should be 1st film bellas human experiances and the second her immortal ones there will only ever be one twilight saga so DO IT RIGHT !!! and it will be worth waiting for. there sould so be sex scense in it not to be crude but it is part of the story and part of her life experiances they have the chance to make this one of the most amazing films ever and they cant stop now . oh and people READ THE GOD DAM BOOKS WHATS WRONG WITH U !!!!!!
  • jennah16
    anything were i can see robert pattinson shirtless is fine with me :D
  • TeamJacward_Original
    I agree with you on everything, someone who sees straight! haha.

    and they really should put the at least "leading up" to the sex scenes, its a major part of the beginning, and it starts the whole book!!
  • rachaelcullenxxsagalover
    i really really really really hope they make breaking dawn!!!!!!!!!!!!in 2 movies becasue it would not fit in one unless they made it lek 5 hours long which i wouldnt mind at all!!!and i would love for the samw cast to b in it because they r unreplaceable!!!
  • Tara
    I agree with the first two posts....To truly appreciate the Twilight Saga, you HAVE to READ THE BOOKS!!
    That said, I would love to see Breaking Dawn made, it is my favorite in the series.
  • shewolf8
    i agree it does have too be two movies, i mean the book is 3 books in one and if they make it one movie their going to cut a lot of stuff out to make it short and then breaking dawn will be horriable. they cant make a 5 hour movie thats not how it works in the mvie making buisness. they willnt allow it,,, so im up for two movies than having them cut a hole bunch of stuff and having it be terriable..... any one agree with me?????? i'd rather have two aswome movies than one horriable one that makes no since.......
  • rimali87
    you have movies like Lord of the Rings and Titanic, why not just make one longer movie? I would hate to finally get to see Breaking Dawn and they chop out important things and add an ending that isn't necessary just so that there will be a 5th movie.
  • rimali87
    I am trying to get my daughter cast as the role of Renesmee! I have no resources so I am hoping the right person will notice her. Any help?
    Please check out my youtube video of her! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2RuUdWOBDP0
blog comments powered by Disqus