Variety ponders Summit’s ‘Twilight’ Dilemma

breaking dawn
[Cheers to Pablo for making this Breaking Dawn banner. Repeat, it is FAN MADE!]

A new article from Variety suggests that Summit has a delimma in dealing with production of a film version of the fourth book in the series, Breaking Dawn. Mainly, there is the money issue if they choose to make two more films, instead of one. In addition, they have figure out what director will be involved (Chris Weitz is a fan favorite).

They will likely have to cut a few big checks if they decided, as rumored, to split Stephenie Meyer’s final “Twilight” novel, “Breaking Dawn,” into two pictures. Sources said Summit has set Melissa Rosenberg — who wrote the first three films — to finish the series, but Summit has to clear several hurdles before Rosenberg learns how many more scripts she’ll write.

One of those hurdles is figuring out whether “New Moon” director Chris Weitz will respond favorably to overtures from the film company and the cast to shoot two more films, back to back.

Summit execs would not comment, but multiple sources said the company wants to go the two-film route, which means reopening negotiations and securing approval from the author. It also means making new deals with a principal cast that is only locked up for four films. If “Breaking Dawn” becomes two pictures, all of the key cast members will get fat raises, and the three principals — Robert Pattinson, Kristen Stewart and Taylor Lautner — could land paydays in the eight-figure range.

Read more here.

My guess is that the payoff at the box office will be big enough to warrent the extra expenditure on the front end.


  • It will be made... it's all about tricky negotiations now. Everyone sees what a "cash cow" it is and wants more for their part, and I don't blame them. It would be stupid to go this far into the franchise and not finish it off. Plus, there are so many, ahem, ignorant "non-readers" who are fans now. Please forgive me for the insult, but I'm just annoyed at everyone complaining about the end to "New Moon." READ PEOPLE!!!
  • Claire0504
    Totally agree with your comment, to fully appreciate the twilight saga you need to READ THE BOOKS!!!!!!
  • rachaelcullenxxsagalover
    ya i totally agree wit u both i hate how people r such fans but its only because of taylor i mean ya hes friken hot but read the books!!!if ur going to see it!!it just bugs me that people want to see it soo bad but its not because they read the books!!!!
  • twihard_twilighter
    yeah me too. ppl need to read the books to understand the relations and feel the intensity.
    waiting for really long detailed breaking dawn. plz dont let our hopes down
  • Sooo agree with you! I heard this couple say that they weren't gonna watch the next movie just because of the way it ended and it's like UMM READ thats how it ends! But I really hope they just get everything that needs to be in there in the movie because it is the final book and the last of the series, my FAVORITE book and I would be soooo pissed if it was the worse movie =(
  • barrelracer1045
    right... and they are all like its too long blah blah blah thats what i thought at first but once you start reading them your stuck to them and its like you HAVE to read the next book ... I have friends that just went to see the movies and it ticks me off soo bad that they wont even bother to read the books... Breaking Dawn is my favorite also
  • riojones96
    I completely agree with you! I have friends that think are the TOP twilight saga fans before me (I've read every book 6 times) while my friends haven't even gotten through twilight
  • Rizam
    I completely agree with you .. !!
    PEOPLE SHOULD READ BEFORE WATCHING ..!!
  • Gabby
    lmfao!!!! Well, I was one of them, but it's just cuz I expected something else, not that it was bad, just expected something else. Btw, it's all about the money!!! As Cuba Gooding Jr's character said: SHOW ME THE MONEY! That's all about!! But I'm pretty sure that they'll engross their accounts with everysingle movie they're producing!! It's pretty dumb to tell us that they're not gonna be a "Breaking Dawn" film... Comm'on! Cheer up! It'll be! And I prefer 2 parts instead of sitting 5 hrs in a movie theatre! My butt won't stand it up that long!
  • emjjjmiller
    I, too, prefer a two-part Breaking Dawn. If they try to condense it into one film, a lot of the small details that we all so dearly love will be lost. I've been thinking about where they would break the book up and I think it would be awesome to have the "Part 1" film include the wedding, the honeymoon on Isle Esme, the pregnancy, the birth of Renesmee, Bella's transformation....and end right as she awakens into her new life. "Part 2" Would be about her new life as a vampire with her new family. Her meeting Renesmee and becoming a mother. Jacob's imprinting. The cottage (and of course night's with Edward!!). Then build to the coming of the Volturi after Irina sees Renesmee hunting w/ Bella and Jacob and assumes she's an immortal child. Plus we have to see Bella developing her talent and when she's a bad-ass with J. Jenks. What do you all think?
  • caitiesullivan
    I think it would be amazing to end the first Breaking Dawn with Bella laying on the table in the Cullens house and the very very last thing you see is a straight down shot on Bella's bright red eyes flashing open.
    I can see it now :)
  • teamedwardalwys
    SO AGREE!! EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT
  • Team Jakeward!
    oh yes, i think that, should they actually make one movie, they would leave nearly all the little details out. it's just too big of a book to make into a single movie, though i hate that i'd have to wait another year or so before i see the last half. I think, as someone who's read Breaking Dawn 8 times, that it would be better as two movies.
  • lrhine2315
    wow...my thoughts exactly!!! I was thinking the same do the first movie up until Bella is turned and the second start when she awakens a Vampire!!........Great Twi-hard minds think alike!! :)
  • AN3LA
    haha i agree with you! :)
  • maree72
    I love that idea only I would rather see Kathrine be more apart of the directing. She at least captured intense moods between Bella and Edward I think through the music she implemented into the first movie. I finally figured out what was rubbing me raw on the second one.. it was the music.. it wasn't blending well for me tho the humor was great. It will be interesting to see what this third director has done with Eclipse. And even more interesting to see how much of the wolves characters they build on should they split book four up into two movies.
  • teamedwardalwys
    i thought the music was great but i do have to say Kathrine was better about directing the acting! I was very suprised at how not great it was in a couple parts in new moon :( I appreciate both movies for different reasons.. both of them were better in some ways but worse in others.
  • FenellaCullen
    YES! i ahave to say i totally agree!! When i went to see New Moon at the cinema with my fello twilight folk and Edward said his 'one condition', people actually gasped and were shocked!! as we walked out people were talking about it and wondering what she would say!!
    They have to make breaking dawn because as you rightly called them, the 'non-readers' will have no idea of how it ends.
  • TwilightsDreamAngel
    I so agree with you Alison! I ever way ...
    Lets just hope Sumitt Does Not go to the Extra Greed and Stupid root and screw the whole thing up!
  • Lovin_at_forks
    i so agree with ya!!! i read this mu life is average (a web site) story of so called twilight fans that freaked out because to make them worried a guy said that "it was too bad edward dies at the end" i was like freaking OUT! they call themselves fans but they don't even read the books!!
  • edwardloverrr
    omg i love mylifeisaverage.com its amazing!!!
  • anriettec
    If you would like to see Breaking Dawn in one long movie, please tweet #OneFilmBreakingDawn if you have Twitter. If we try hard enough, maybe we can get it trending. If we get it trending, then Summit will see we are serious about NOT having Breaking Dawn split up.

    Please people, we are the fans, and it is up to us to influence decisions. Breaking Dawn's screenplay haven't been written yet, so there is still a chance for us to fix this.

    Tweet #OneFilmBreakingDawn AND (#Twilight or #NewMoon or #Eclipse) and direct it at @Twilight. Like this:

    @Twilight We need a #OneFilmBreakingDawn #Twilight #NewMoon #Eclipse.

    Please people, let's get this trending.
  • caitiesullivan
    That's so dumb.
    Why would you want it in one movie?

    As a Twilight fan, wouldn't you want as many Twilight movies as you can get?

    And if they make it one movie, do you KNOW how much they'll have to cut out.
    Let's see, Edward and Bella would have to get married, have the reception, talk to Jake, go to the honey moon, spend a week there, get preggo, fly back to America, talk to Carlisle, get sick, see Jake and the wolves debating whether or not to kill her, Bella get even worse and worse, Bella fall over and start having the baby, Jake and Edward trying to deliever the baby, Jake giving up, and finally Bella waking up all in about ONE HOUR. That would be a big piece of crap.

    Sorry to bash your idea, but it's obvious you didn't think it out. Sowwee
  • ironchick
    they will do it! there is no way after all the boxoffice records were demolished and the huge worldwide love of the books and the films. I really do hope they make Breaking Dawn into 2 films; that way they wont have to cut too much out.

    I also agree with you Alison. I have heard several compliants from 'nonreaders' and all I keep telling them is that the books are amazing and they are cheating themselves out of an addicting read by skipping them!
  • Samantha
    make it ONE movie!!., itd be wak to go bak to watch the second partt...wth..titanic was about 4 hrs. long, and a hell of a lotta ppl sat through that!.our butts will be sore,,but it'll be worth it for twilight fans.
blog comments powered by Disqus