Comments on: WSJ: Can Twilight and Harry Potter co-exist? http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/ Movie News, Pics & Fan Site Thu, 09 Feb 2012 14:21:11 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.1.3 By: Geneva Nodwell http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-139139 Geneva Nodwell Sat, 30 Jan 2010 02:23:14 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-139139 personally, i like both twilight and harry potter personally, i like both twilight and harry potter

]]> By: Geneva Nodwell http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-134285 Geneva Nodwell Fri, 29 Jan 2010 21:23:14 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-134285 personally, i like both twilight and harry potter personally, i like both twilight and harry potter

]]> By: PILCH http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-134286 PILCH Sat, 12 Dec 2009 20:57:37 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-134286 Yes! I completely agree - I was into Harry Potter WAY before Twilight and I read the Twilight series and instantly fell in love with it. Both Harry Potter and Twilight are such different stories and books that it IS possible to love both of them! I think it's silly and narrow-minded of people to just criticise one or the other and compare them all the time. Can people not accept that they can both be REALLY good?! Yes! I completely agree – I was into Harry Potter WAY before Twilight and I read the Twilight series and instantly fell in love with it. Both Harry Potter and Twilight are such different stories and books that it IS possible to love both of them! I think it's silly and narrow-minded of people to just criticise one or the other and compare them all the time. Can people not accept that they can both be REALLY good?!

]]> By: vampireQueen01 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-134287 vampireQueen01 Fri, 06 Nov 2009 22:16:17 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-134287 i prefer harry potter over twilight because it is so much more creative and complex than a simple romance! Jk Rowling has established a whole new world, where as, Stephanie meyer simply based her ideas off of previous vampire books! if you want to read something by stephanie meyer you should read "the Host". it is, by far, the best of her work! i prefer harry potter over twilight because it is so much more creative and complex than a simple romance! Jk Rowling has established a whole new world, where as, Stephanie meyer simply based her ideas off of previous vampire books! if you want to read something by stephanie meyer you should read “the Host”. it is, by far, the best of her work!

]]> By: vampireQueen01 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-134288 vampireQueen01 Fri, 06 Nov 2009 22:11:46 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-134288 I dont know...i love them both and must say that vampires are so much cooler than wizards, but, i still think Harry potter is better! the only reason people are so caught on the whole Twilight saga is because its simple to read! Stephanie Meyer has created a simple romantic plot, but J.K. Rowling has created a whole new world! Heck, she came up with an elite school, a sport, and even spells! i think she is a complete genious! If you want to read somethimg stephanie meyer wrote with a more complex outlet, you should read "The Host"! it is definetly the best of her work and it has some REAL creative background! I dont know…i love them both and must say that vampires are so much cooler than wizards, but, i still think Harry potter is better! the only reason people are so caught on the whole Twilight saga is because its simple to read! Stephanie Meyer has created a simple romantic plot, but J.K. Rowling has created a whole new world! Heck, she came up with an elite school, a sport, and even spells! i think she is a complete genious! If you want to read somethimg stephanie meyer wrote with a more complex outlet, you should read “The Host”! it is definetly the best of her work and it has some REAL creative background!

]]> By: valeribella http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-134289 valeribella Sun, 27 Sep 2009 00:36:02 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-134289 this is so stupid. the only reason that people are comparing both movies is because robert pattinson appears in both stories. i like both i like twilight more but i like BOTH... just if you dont like HP dont see it, if you dont like TWILIGHT DONT SEE IT, but if you LIKE BOTH, SEE IT AND PLZZZ DO NOT COMPARE THERE IS NOTHING TO COMPARE. <br>TEAM EDWARD BY THE WAY lol this is so stupid. the only reason that people are comparing both movies is because robert pattinson appears in both stories. i like both i like twilight more but i like BOTH… just if you dont like HP dont see it, if you dont like TWILIGHT DONT SEE IT, but if you LIKE BOTH, SEE IT AND PLZZZ DO NOT COMPARE THERE IS NOTHING TO COMPARE.
TEAM EDWARD BY THE WAY lol

]]> By: tiffanilauchlann http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-134290 tiffanilauchlann Tue, 28 Jul 2009 12:12:08 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-134290 Tbh, harry potter has been the one thing i look forward too, the new movies and stuff ever since it first came out, i've loved it...<br>harry potter has more in it, and if you read the books you are ready for the movies because you kno they will be amazing and realistic.<br>don't get me wrong twilight has captured my heart, the stories sometimes makes me cry at how heartfelt it is, i just love it... the story its self a love story i just love it, and robert pattinson just makes Edward amazing, no one can make him better, but i do say harry potter is amazing but also twilight, so alone i can't make this decision to say what is beter.. there both truely amazing (LLLLLLLLLLL) Tbh, harry potter has been the one thing i look forward too, the new movies and stuff ever since it first came out, i've loved it…
harry potter has more in it, and if you read the books you are ready for the movies because you kno they will be amazing and realistic.
don't get me wrong twilight has captured my heart, the stories sometimes makes me cry at how heartfelt it is, i just love it… the story its self a love story i just love it, and robert pattinson just makes Edward amazing, no one can make him better, but i do say harry potter is amazing but also twilight, so alone i can't make this decision to say what is beter.. there both truely amazing (LLLLLLLLLLL)

]]> By: twilightobbsessed16 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-107758 twilightobbsessed16 Sun, 26 Jul 2009 11:25:20 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-107758 i like both twilight and harry potter but the problem with both film is that i feel like there should be more to it i feel like the directors leave massive important chumks out of the film that are in the book and i find that really dissapointing because i would rather the film was better than the books but the books are atchully better than the films :( x p.s. i love you rob!!! xxx i like both twilight and harry potter but the problem with both film is that i feel like there should be more to it i feel like the directors leave massive important chumks out of the film that are in the book and i find that really dissapointing because i would rather the film was better than the books but the books are atchully better than the films :( x p.s. i love you rob!!! xxx

]]> By: twilightobbsessed16 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-85498 twilightobbsessed16 Sun, 26 Jul 2009 08:25:20 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-85498 i like both twilight and harry potter but the problem with both film is that i feel like there should be more to it i feel like the directors leave massive important chumks out of the film that are in the book and i find that really dissapointing because i would rather the film was better than the books but the books are atchully better than the films :( x p.s. i love you rob!!! xxx i like both twilight and harry potter but the problem with both film is that i feel like there should be more to it i feel like the directors leave massive important chumks out of the film that are in the book and i find that really dissapointing because i would rather the film was better than the books but the books are atchully better than the films :( x p.s. i love you rob!!! xxx

]]> By: ParisFreak http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-85499 ParisFreak Thu, 23 Jul 2009 07:53:51 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-85499 I must say that what the article above shows is correct.<br>i LOVE Harry Potter,and i have read evry book.The HP books are amazing,and one of a kind.they may be similar to Twilight,but fans who just jump from HP to Twilight are losers.no offence.i LOVE Twilight.ALOT.so do i love HP to.<br>but even now,im going 2 read all the bks. again,of both!!<br><br>That's just called stupidity.throwing HP away,and going of to Twilight!!!?<br>Ofcourse,you SHOULD read both,but still!<br>dont give up on HP!<br>J.K Rowling didnt become famous for nothing!<br>neither did Stephanie Meyer!<br>so people,stop this childdishness of urs!<br>and no,it does have 2 do with which came first.in a way..<br>Poeple used 2 go like:"OH MY GOD!!HARRY POTTEEEERRR"<br>waiting in the middle of the nt. infront of bookstores for part 7!!<br>it was ALLLL over the news.<br>they are both different,but similar in a slight way,that what,there's love?!<br>and no person everrr can compare HP and Twilightt!<br>and this is not a fight to see who gets the "throne".<br>what the hell people!!<br>Grow up!<br>God! I must say that what the article above shows is correct.
i LOVE Harry Potter,and i have read evry book.The HP books are amazing,and one of a kind.they may be similar to Twilight,but fans who just jump from HP to Twilight are losers.no offence.i LOVE Twilight.ALOT.so do i love HP to.
but even now,im going 2 read all the bks. again,of both!!

That's just called stupidity.throwing HP away,and going of to Twilight!!!?
Ofcourse,you SHOULD read both,but still!
dont give up on HP!
J.K Rowling didnt become famous for nothing!
neither did Stephanie Meyer!
so people,stop this childdishness of urs!
and no,it does have 2 do with which came first.in a way..
Poeple used 2 go like:”OH MY GOD!!HARRY POTTEEEERRR”
waiting in the middle of the nt. infront of bookstores for part 7!!
it was ALLLL over the news.
they are both different,but similar in a slight way,that what,there's love?!
and no person everrr can compare HP and Twilightt!
and this is not a fight to see who gets the “throne”.
what the hell people!!
Grow up!
God!

]]> By: jbrooke http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-84420 jbrooke Wed, 22 Jul 2009 03:24:15 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-84420 If that is all you think Twilight consists of, then you obviously haven't even read it. If that is all you think Twilight consists of, then you obviously haven't even read it.

]]> By: nisa http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-83979 nisa Sun, 19 Jul 2009 15:54:24 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-83979 how is that stupid how is that stupid

]]> By: harrypotterswaybetter http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-83731 harrypotterswaybetter Fri, 17 Jul 2009 13:33:51 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-83731 i no rite i no rite

]]> By: harrypotterswaybetter http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-83727 harrypotterswaybetter Fri, 17 Jul 2009 13:28:44 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-83727 no its not! its stupid no its not! its stupid

]]> By: harrypotterswaybetter http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-83725 harrypotterswaybetter Fri, 17 Jul 2009 13:27:19 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-83725 omg ur are a total idiot who has no taste whatsoever!! twilight constits of <br>i lov you<br>i love u to<br>but im a vampire <br>i love you <br>i love you 2<br>but im a vampire<br>idiots rite that stuff and other idiots like it! harrry potter has depth and reason and all its plots are intersting and exciting. it incorperates many differnt ideas and emothins and ur jjust a total .... omg ur are a total idiot who has no taste whatsoever!! twilight constits of
i lov you
i love u to
but im a vampire
i love you
i love you 2
but im a vampire
idiots rite that stuff and other idiots like it! harrry potter has depth and reason and all its plots are intersting and exciting. it incorperates many differnt ideas and emothins and ur jjust a total ….

]]> By: Florence http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-83390 Florence Tue, 14 Jul 2009 17:23:14 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-83390 I agree that Twilight has a better story line, and if Twilight was as well written as Harry Potter then it would be by far the better of the two series, but I am also a devout Harry Potter fan. I believe that both books are fantaastic and you are right in saying that they shouldn't be compared because they are so different. If one person doesn't enjoy one of the series, then they don't have to read it! It is like everyone is being split into two groups, the Harry Potter fans and the Twilight fans, whereas what it all comes down to is that it really doesn't matter what everyone's personal preferences are and you should just read and watch what you find to be enjoyable to you, not what your friends or other people think you should read. I agree that Twilight has a better story line, and if Twilight was as well written as Harry Potter then it would be by far the better of the two series, but I am also a devout Harry Potter fan. I believe that both books are fantaastic and you are right in saying that they shouldn't be compared because they are so different. If one person doesn't enjoy one of the series, then they don't have to read it! It is like everyone is being split into two groups, the Harry Potter fans and the Twilight fans, whereas what it all comes down to is that it really doesn't matter what everyone's personal preferences are and you should just read and watch what you find to be enjoyable to you, not what your friends or other people think you should read.

]]> By: Ivonnnegreen http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82963 Ivonnnegreen Mon, 13 Jul 2009 02:03:55 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82963 I totally agree with you too. I watched the first HP movie when I was 9, and every year since then, I've expected the releases of the books or the movies with excitement. I liked the Twilight series so much too, but I've been a HP fan for almost half of my short life, so I see the HP series closer to me and my life experiences. And it's a waste of time to discuss which one is better, because everything is based on people's taste, so everything is subjective. I totally agree with you too. I watched the first HP movie when I was 9, and every year since then, I've expected the releases of the books or the movies with excitement. I liked the Twilight series so much too, but I've been a HP fan for almost half of my short life, so I see the HP series closer to me and my life experiences. And it's a waste of time to discuss which one is better, because everything is based on people's taste, so everything is subjective.

]]> By: Ivonnnegreen http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82946 Ivonnnegreen Sun, 12 Jul 2009 23:03:55 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82946 I totally agree with you too. I watched the first HP movie when I was 9, and every year since then, I've expected the releases of the books or the movies with excitement. I liked the Twilight series so much too, but I've been a HP fan for almost half of my short life, so I see the HP series closer to me and my life experiences. And it's a waste of time to discuss which one is better, because everything is based on people's taste, so everything is subjective. I totally agree with you too. I watched the first HP movie when I was 9, and every year since then, I've expected the releases of the books or the movies with excitement. I liked the Twilight series so much too, but I've been a HP fan for almost half of my short life, so I see the HP series closer to me and my life experiences. And it's a waste of time to discuss which one is better, because everything is based on people's taste, so everything is subjective.

]]> By: kim http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82931 kim Sat, 11 Jul 2009 17:20:48 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82931 wonderfully said :] wonderfully said :]

]]> By: jamerz101 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82929 jamerz101 Sat, 11 Jul 2009 16:20:40 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82929 Your on a twilight fan site... to say it sucks, what's the point visiting the site to abuse it? Your on a twilight fan site… to say it sucks, what's the point visiting the site to abuse it?

]]> By: C.B http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82918 C.B Sat, 11 Jul 2009 13:52:35 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82918 everyone knows that? :P everyone knows that? :P

]]> By: rockster_11 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82910 rockster_11 Sat, 11 Jul 2009 11:56:56 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82910 your opinion is yours i guess, but really, romeo and juliet was exactly the same, and no-one complains about that do they? they all think it was a beautiful love story about people who LOVED each other very much. it all comes down to opinion - i think that romeo and juliet's love was lust, and i agree with you to an extent, as people cant fall in love at first sight in my opinion. but still, its a cute story, incredibly they stay together, and its just good reading. again, in MY opinion. your opinion is yours i guess, but really, romeo and juliet was exactly the same, and no-one complains about that do they? they all think it was a beautiful love story about people who LOVED each other very much. it all comes down to opinion – i think that romeo and juliet's love was lust, and i agree with you to an extent, as people cant fall in love at first sight in my opinion. but still, its a cute story, incredibly they stay together, and its just good reading. again, in MY opinion.

]]> By: rockster_11 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82909 rockster_11 Sat, 11 Jul 2009 11:53:25 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82909 so did i! honestly, people can tell u know : so did i! honestly, people can tell u know :

]]> By: rockster_11 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82908 rockster_11 Sat, 11 Jul 2009 11:49:11 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82908 i completely agree with you. i think that j.k.rowling is a much better author, no offence, but twilight's plot is amazing. i find that i can quite easily love them both very much, and i have no problem reading harry potter and the goblet of fire and breaking dawn at the same time. i completely agree with you. i think that j.k.rowling is a much better author, no offence, but twilight's plot is amazing. i find that i can quite easily love them both very much, and i have no problem reading harry potter and the goblet of fire and breaking dawn at the same time.

]]> By: brownie(: http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82899 brownie(: Sat, 11 Jul 2009 08:45:39 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82899 i knew that :) i knew that :)

]]> By: Pusher32 http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82867 Pusher32 Sat, 11 Jul 2009 02:39:58 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82867 am i the only one that knows that Rob Pattinson started out in harry potter by playing Cedric Diggory in the 4th movie am i the only one that knows that Rob Pattinson started out in harry potter by playing Cedric Diggory in the 4th movie

]]> By: nisa http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82820 nisa Fri, 10 Jul 2009 20:25:10 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82820 i cant wait the trailer is not enough i cant wait the trailer is not enough

]]> By: nisa http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82819 nisa Fri, 10 Jul 2009 20:24:14 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82819 yea...i think twlight was one big story that had to be cut up in 4....harry potter has diffrent eventd from his life...diffrent stories...twlight is just one not really a seris yea…i think twlight was one big story that had to be cut up in 4….harry potter has diffrent eventd from his life…diffrent stories…twlight is just one not really a seris

]]> By: nisa http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-2/#comment-82818 nisa Fri, 10 Jul 2009 20:22:22 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82818 yea...i mean both r mythical to some extent...who doesnt like stories that u can daydream about coming tru yea…i mean both r mythical to some extent…who doesnt like stories that u can daydream about coming tru

]]> By: nisa http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82817 nisa Fri, 10 Jul 2009 20:20:16 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82817 so rite so rite

]]> By: nisa http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82816 nisa Fri, 10 Jul 2009 20:19:33 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82816 i mostly agree with u...i only ready like 2 of hp book once and ive ready twlight saga like more than 5 times each..its also like the story plot that ppl is n love with...vampires and a forbidden romance and it corresponds with teenagers and up i mostly agree with u…i only ready like 2 of hp book once and ive ready twlight saga like more than 5 times each..its also like the story plot that ppl is n love with…vampires and a forbidden romance and it corresponds with teenagers and up

]]> By: Ruthie Medina-Ilasco http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82815 Ruthie Medina-Ilasco Fri, 10 Jul 2009 19:15:24 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82815 Wonderfully said. :) And true, of course . :) Wonderfully said. :) And true, of course . :)

]]> By: Ruthie Medina-Ilasco http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82791 Ruthie Medina-Ilasco Fri, 10 Jul 2009 19:12:58 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82791 I quite agree with Rosa in this one with regards to Harry Potter having a lot of plots and sub-plots whereas Twilight is more of a one plot story. <br> <br>But I don't believe that one is better than the other. Both are good, great even. It's just that they both have different genres and different focuses. <br><br>I am a huge fan of both, movies and books alike. But I will never say that one is better than the other just because, for example - the actors who acted in it. Check the content of the books before saying anything else. :) Love and peace! I quite agree with Rosa in this one with regards to Harry Potter having a lot of plots and sub-plots whereas Twilight is more of a one plot story.

But I don't believe that one is better than the other. Both are good, great even. It's just that they both have different genres and different focuses.

I am a huge fan of both, movies and books alike. But I will never say that one is better than the other just because, for example – the actors who acted in it. Check the content of the books before saying anything else. :) Love and peace!

]]> By: Pfft. http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82761 Pfft. Fri, 10 Jul 2009 17:26:36 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82761 Twilight sucks.<br><br>it's not even a love story, it's a lust story. They don't even love each other.<br><br>Edward is majorly controlling and emotionally abusive, bella is a mary sue- not only that, but she is a huge whiner. Jacob imprints on a newborn, Quil imprints on a two year old: what is RIGHT about that? Twilight sucks.

it's not even a love story, it's a lust story. They don't even love each other.

Edward is majorly controlling and emotionally abusive, bella is a mary sue- not only that, but she is a huge whiner. Jacob imprints on a newborn, Quil imprints on a two year old: what is RIGHT about that?

]]> By: Acacia Abar http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82745 Acacia Abar Fri, 10 Jul 2009 16:22:52 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82745 Twilight and Harry Potter are from different genres though. I don't understand how you can compare them because they are so different. But, I am excited for both of them to come out. Twilight and Harry Potter are from different genres though. I don't understand how you can compare them because they are so different. But, I am excited for both of them to come out.

]]> By: pheonixfawkes http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82744 pheonixfawkes Fri, 10 Jul 2009 15:57:00 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82744 It can't be classic if it's new. I love both HP and Twilight, but I think twilight is better because it is well rounded. It has a bit of everything. It can't be classic if it's new. I love both HP and Twilight, but I think twilight is better because it is well rounded. It has a bit of everything.

]]> By: Zoe Hinks http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82736 Zoe Hinks Fri, 10 Jul 2009 14:59:28 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82736 i totally agree :) x i totally agree :) x

]]> By: ArM.. http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82735 ArM.. Fri, 10 Jul 2009 14:58:25 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82735 you know, i dont think they should be compared in any way because one is a classic love story and the other a fantisy. Harry Potter was never known for its love story and is amazing in its self as is twilight. honestly you can love both with out having to pick one. at the moment im excited for Harry Potter but in a couple months later il be excited about New Moon. they are different and cannot be compared :) you know, i dont think they should be compared in any way because one is a classic love story and the other a fantisy. Harry Potter was never known for its love story and is amazing in its self as is twilight. honestly you can love both with out having to pick one. at the moment im excited for Harry Potter but in a couple months later il be excited about New Moon. they are different and cannot be compared :)

]]> By: Emily http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82731 Emily Fri, 10 Jul 2009 14:38:06 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82731 thats pretty much the same thing with me. they werent for school. my friends told me to read them so i did. it took me a while to finally give in and read twilight because i didnt want to get into something that everyone was into. but when i finally did, i read it in like 2 days. where as with harry potter it has taken me over a year to read each of the books. im not into reading AT ALL. but twilight totally changed my mind. thats pretty much the same thing with me. they werent for school. my friends told me to read them so i did. it took me a while to finally give in and read twilight because i didnt want to get into something that everyone was into. but when i finally did, i read it in like 2 days. where as with harry potter it has taken me over a year to read each of the books. im not into reading AT ALL. but twilight totally changed my mind.

]]> By: twicrazified http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82725 twicrazified Fri, 10 Jul 2009 14:25:31 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82725 soooo true i read the first chapter of hp and hated every word of it then in late may my friend walks up and says have you read twilight and im like no and she shoves the book into me and when i got home and started readin it i couldnt put the book down i honestly didnt get any sleep at all that night <br>twilight definatly gets my vote soooo true i read the first chapter of hp and hated every word of it then in late may my friend walks up and says have you read twilight and im like no and she shoves the book into me and when i got home and started readin it i couldnt put the book down i honestly didnt get any sleep at all that night
twilight definatly gets my vote

]]> By: Michelle http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82723 Michelle Fri, 10 Jul 2009 14:16:48 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82723 I'm 29 with kids, :). I absolutely agree with you about twilight. They really aren't comparable. I just prefer the Twilight movies, because I feel they follow the story line better. They change so much in the Potter Movies, that it drives me crazy...so I just stick with the books for those. Otherwise the stories aren't that compairable in that they've made so many younger kids begin reading. In Twiligihts defense though, more girls will appreciate it than guys. My 15 yr old sister wouldn't go near Harry Potter, but she read the Twilight series. I think they're the first books she's read that weren't for school. Lol. I'm 29 with kids, :) . I absolutely agree with you about twilight. They really aren't comparable. I just prefer the Twilight movies, because I feel they follow the story line better. They change so much in the Potter Movies, that it drives me crazy…so I just stick with the books for those. Otherwise the stories aren't that compairable in that they've made so many younger kids begin reading. In Twiligihts defense though, more girls will appreciate it than guys. My 15 yr old sister wouldn't go near Harry Potter, but she read the Twilight series. I think they're the first books she's read that weren't for school. Lol.

]]> By: twicrazified http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82722 twicrazified Fri, 10 Jul 2009 14:12:59 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82722 twilight wins by far for me there should be no comparison i have always hated hp and i always will twilight will always be da best <br>NOVEMBER isnt comin quick enough twilight wins by far for me there should be no comparison i have always hated hp and i always will twilight will always be da best
NOVEMBER isnt comin quick enough

]]> By: b vargas http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82713 b vargas Fri, 10 Jul 2009 13:13:24 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82713 u cant be compare. u are awesome!!! u cant be compare. u are awesome!!!

]]> By: RosaPhoenix http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82704 RosaPhoenix Fri, 10 Jul 2009 10:33:18 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82704 harry potter is so much better. twilight is a fairly good love story, yes. but harry potter has so many plots and sub-plots that weave in and out of each other and that make genuine sense. Stephanie Meyer isn't that great at sub-plots, she just happened across a good, sellable idea. JK Rowling thought of a great idea and then expanded on it and make it intelligent. there is no comparison between the two franchises, harry potter will always be better. harry potter is so much better. twilight is a fairly good love story, yes. but harry potter has so many plots and sub-plots that weave in and out of each other and that make genuine sense. Stephanie Meyer isn't that great at sub-plots, she just happened across a good, sellable idea. JK Rowling thought of a great idea and then expanded on it and make it intelligent. there is no comparison between the two franchises, harry potter will always be better.

]]> By: aliceeee http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82703 aliceeee Fri, 10 Jul 2009 10:24:26 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82703 does it really matter which one was here first? its to do with which one is better.. and twilight definately wins that debate does it really matter which one was here first? its to do with which one is better.. and twilight definately wins that debate

]]> By: Mimi http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82699 Mimi Fri, 10 Jul 2009 09:54:24 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82699 I am sooooo excited for the 15th! (I live in Wales) Me and my friends have been waiting for this film for aaages!! And it looks so good! =D<br>But back to the original point, you can't compare Twilight and Harry Potter, they're too different. They're both amazing books, but personally I think Harry Potter is a more original idea, and what's this nonsense about Harry Potter copying Twilight?! Harry and Ginny got together waaay before Edward and Bella, and are a big part of HP 6, so of course they're gonna be in a poster together...<br>Anyway, I love both of them a lot =D I am sooooo excited for the 15th! (I live in Wales) Me and my friends have been waiting for this film for aaages!! And it looks so good! =D
But back to the original point, you can't compare Twilight and Harry Potter, they're too different. They're both amazing books, but personally I think Harry Potter is a more original idea, and what's this nonsense about Harry Potter copying Twilight?! Harry and Ginny got together waaay before Edward and Bella, and are a big part of HP 6, so of course they're gonna be in a poster together…
Anyway, I love both of them a lot =D

]]> By: kito http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82696 kito Fri, 10 Jul 2009 06:54:45 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82696 ummm no.. Harry Potter was here first and this is like a typical fight for the throne... as for your comment of no comparison..of course not..how can you compare harry potter to twilight? not dissing on it, but HP was here first :) ummm no.. Harry Potter was here first and this is like a typical fight for the throne… as for your comment of no comparison..of course not..how can you compare harry potter to twilight? not dissing on it, but HP was here first :)

]]> By: katy http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82695 katy Fri, 10 Jul 2009 06:49:30 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82695 i love both the harry potter series and twilight, they have both been able to keep me out of my own world thats why i read books, there is no need to copare harry potter was released ages b4 twilight the only thing that has made ppl comare the two is because of the films which is rediclulous YOU CAN LOVE MORE THAN ONE SERIES OF BOOKS AT THE SAME TIME. i love both the harry potter series and twilight, they have both been able to keep me out of my own world thats why i read books, there is no need to copare harry potter was released ages b4 twilight the only thing that has made ppl comare the two is because of the films which is rediclulous YOU CAN LOVE MORE THAN ONE SERIES OF BOOKS AT THE SAME TIME.

]]> By: Chelsea http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82694 Chelsea Fri, 10 Jul 2009 06:24:44 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82694 it does make sense if u read the whole book. it does make sense if u read the whole book.

]]> By: Chelsea http://team-twilight.com/20090709/wsj-twilight-harry-potter-coexist/comment-page-1/#comment-82693 Chelsea Fri, 10 Jul 2009 06:22:02 +0000 http://team-twilight.com/?p=2119#comment-82693 all i ahve got to say is i love both series but i love twilight more; i can relate to it engages u more. Twilight books are better than the film but the film is awsome too. Hrry potter books are not as good as the films because they are a bit confusing whereas the films make more sense. Over all i love twilight. There shuldnt be comparisons because they are both brilliant series. Harry potter does finish soon but u have to remember that twilight hits a range of year and both sex so i believe that twilight will b as big as harry potter. After harry finishes in bout a years tym Twilight will still be going so ppl might forget all bout harry potter. Im not saying they will but they might? all i ahve got to say is i love both series but i love twilight more; i can relate to it engages u more. Twilight books are better than the film but the film is awsome too. Hrry potter books are not as good as the films because they are a bit confusing whereas the films make more sense. Over all i love twilight. There shuldnt be comparisons because they are both brilliant series. Harry potter does finish soon but u have to remember that twilight hits a range of year and both sex so i believe that twilight will b as big as harry potter. After harry finishes in bout a years tym Twilight will still be going so ppl might forget all bout harry potter. Im not saying they will but they might?

]]>